Point Based On Books The Rules of the Game: Jutland and British Naval Command
Title | : | The Rules of the Game: Jutland and British Naval Command |
Author | : | Gilbert Andrew Hugh Gordon |
Book Format | : | Paperback |
Book Edition | : | Deluxe Edition |
Pages | : | Pages: 708 pages |
Published | : | September 1st 2000 by Naval Institute Press (first published January 1st 1996) |
Categories | : | History. War. Military Fiction. Military. Military History. Naval History. Nonfiction |
Gilbert Andrew Hugh Gordon
Paperback | Pages: 708 pages Rating: 4.38 | 258 Users | 30 Reviews
Narrative Conducive To Books The Rules of the Game: Jutland and British Naval Command
When published in hardcover in 1997, this book was praised for providing an engrossing education not only in naval strategy and tactics but in Victorian social attitudes and the influence of character on history. In juxtaposing an operational with a cultural theme, the author comes closer than any historian yet to explaining what was behind the often described operations of this famous 1916 battle at Jutland. Although the British fleet was victorious over the Germans, the cost in ships and men was high, and debates have raged within British naval circles ever since about why the Royal Navy was unable to take advantage of the situation. In this book Andrew Gordon focuses on what he calls a fault-line between two incompatible styles of tactical leadership within the Royal Navy and different understandings of the rules of the games.Be Specific About Books During The Rules of the Game: Jutland and British Naval Command
Original Title: | The Rules of the Game : Jutland and British Naval Command |
ISBN: | 1557509719 (ISBN13: 9781557509710) |
Edition Language: | English |
Characters: | George Tryon, Horatio Nelson, George V of the United Kingdom, John Fisher, 1st Baron Fisher, David Beatty, 1st Earl Beatty, John Jellicoe, 1st Earl Jellicoe, Reinhard Scheer, Winston Churchill, Franz von Hipper, Ernle Chatfield, 1st Baron Chatfield, Philip Howard Colomb, Sir Michael Culme-Seymour, 3rd Baronet, William Goodenough, Albert Hastings Markham, Arthur Wilson |
Literary Awards: | Duke of Westminster Medal for Military Literature (1997) |
Rating Based On Books The Rules of the Game: Jutland and British Naval Command
Ratings: 4.38 From 258 Users | 30 ReviewsCommentary Based On Books The Rules of the Game: Jutland and British Naval Command
Recently I started reading up some on the Jutland battle. And this title was recommended by many.Did I like the book? Yes and no. To this I need to add, for an honest appraisal of what I write here, that I am not a hardcore naval history reader.What I did like were the parts covering the battle and the eyewitness accounts. I also liked learning some more about the commanders involved and the tactics used. But there were also parts that I didn't enjoy as much. Not liking them is putting it a bitOne of my favorites. A story excellent told with great strategic analysis.
The majority of the book was very dry and hard to read. In my opinion, the author included a little too much biographical cross-references and detailed log activities. I could appreciate the schematic overviews, but they didn't make up for the text. Yet, interesting to read about naval operations and how a peace-mindset is a bad preparation for war.
Vast reading. The book gives an insight on the command and control mentality that lead to the decisions taken during the Battle of jutland and how it developed over a time span that goes from Trafalgar to WW1.
Really good. First as a very detailed look into the battle, then as an analysis of the culture of the Grand Fleet's high command. The middle third dragged a bit, although its importance was obvious.
One of the best accounts I have read that truly explains why the Battle of Jutland unfolded as it did. It covers all the technical and human aspects of the action, as good military history should, but then adds a whole new dimension. Gilbert plunges into the backgrounds of the main protagonists and the morays of the Victorian navy to come at the root causes of why they acted as they did. We are all prisoners of our pasts, great leaders as much as the rest of us. All military history should be
On June 2nd 1916, as the battlefleets returned to their respective anchorages, the question "What in the hell went wrong at Jutland?" began to be asked.Andrew Gordon has gone a long way to suggesting a number of answers in this deeply learned and fascinating book. I'm not really capable of giving it the academic review it deserves, but will note some highlights:1. One of Gordon's main arguments is that the seeds of Jutland were planted in what he calls "the long, calm lee of Trafalgar." The
0 comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.